Euthanasia of Research Animals
Euthanasia - the act of inducing humane death in an animal by a method that induces rapid loss of consciousness and death with a minimum of pain, discomfort or distress.
“Acceptable method” - As defined by the American Veterinary Medical Association, an acceptable method of euthanasia renders an animal unconscious and insensitive to pain and distress as quickly as possible, followed by cessation of all respiratory and circulatory functions and brain activity.
“Acceptable method with Conditions” - These methods are considered “Acceptable” (see above) only if specific conditions are met, as indicated in the AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals: 2013 Edition. For example, neonatal rodents and reptiles may be resistant to the effects of CO2 inhalation – therefore, a secondary physical method to confirm death is required. On the other hand, the preparation for some physical methods (e.g., decapitation) may cause stress in the animals, so administration of a sedative or anesthesia is required. Once the specified conditions are met, these methods are considered fully acceptable under the Guidelines.
To prevent/alleviate animal suffering, all laboratory animals must be euthanized in a timely manner, either as described in the approved protocol according to established timepoints, or as soon as necessary if established criteria or humane endpoints are reached. While every effort will be made to reach a member of the study team in the event that an animal requires early or unscheduled euthanasia due to unrelieved pain/distress, the IACUC has empowered ULAR veterinarians to immediately euthanize any animal that is found near death or suffering from intractable pain. Researchers are advised to ensure that Veterinary Services personnel can always reach someone with authority to deal with sick or injured animals.
All IACUC protocols must include a description of the method(s) that will be used to euthanize animals as well as a description of how death will be confirmed. The method(s) to be used must be consistent with the AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals: 2013 Edition
Since rodents can be particularly resistant to euthanasia by standard methods such as inhalation of CO2 or gas anesthesia, IACUC policy requires that an approved secondary physical method of euthanasia (e.g. decapitation, cervical dislocation, exsanguination or removal of vital organs) be employed prior to carcass disposal in ALL rodent species. Failure to employ both the primary and secondary methods in all animals as described in the protocol will be treated as serious protocol non-compliance.
NOTE: Unintended recovery of animals after apparent death from CO2 or other euthanasia agents constitutes serious regulatory noncompliance. All incidents involving unintended recovery of euthanized animals are reported to the Office of Laboratory Animal Welfare at NIH.
Common Euthanasia Methods
- Inhalation of anesthesia gas– acceptable with conditions for rodents and other small animals (< 7 kg). Typically used as part of a two-step process with a secondary physical method of euthanasia such as decapitation or cervical dislocation.
- Inhalation of CO2 - acceptable with conditions, including the special considerations listed below.
- Immersion agents – e.g. MS 222/Tricaine. Acceptable for aquatic species, usually in connection with a secondary physical method.
- Cervical Dislocation – acceptable for small birds, mice and immature rats. Requires training and should be performed under anesthesia unless specifically approved by the IACUC.
- Decapitation – acceptable for rodents and small rabbits. Requires training; anesthesia recommended unless approved by the IACUC. Guillotines must be sharpened and adjusted frequently to ensure proper performance.
- Injectable barbiturate agents – e.g. sodium pentobarbital, Euthasol®, Eutha 6®, Fatal Plus® - acceptable for most species.
- Exsanguination/Cardiac Perfusion – acceptable with conditions; animals must be anesthetized. The IACUC strongly recommends the use of injectable anethestic agents (sodium pentobarbital, ketamine/xylazine, telazol, etc.) prior to cardiac perfusion.
CO2 (Carbon Dioxide Gas) - Special Considerations for the use of CO2 as a euthanasia agent:
The following additional guidelines must be followed when using CO2:
- CO2 must be delivered from compressed gas canister only. Gas should be delivered using a gradual fill method- a displacement rate from 30% to 70% of the chamber volume per minute is recommended. Use of a flowmeter is strongly recommended.
- Use of dry ice to deliver CO2 gas is unacceptable.
- High concentrations of CO2 have been determined to cause pain and distress. The practice of immersion, where conscious animals are placed directly into a container filled with 100% CO2, is unacceptable.
- Use of the rodents’ home cage is recommended as it minimizes stress in the animals.
- Chambers used for CO2 euthanasia must not be overcrowded. Overcrowding in this situation is defined as less than one half the normal housing space normally required for the animals.
- If animals are removed from their home cages prior to euthanasia, the container used to transport animals between the housing area and procedure room/euthanasia chamber must not be overcrowded.
- Male mice from different cages should not be mixed in transport cages or the euthanasia chamber to prevent distress and/or fighting.
- Detailed instructions for the use of CO2 euthanasia are posted in all vivarium procedure rooms and can be reviewed on the ULAR website.
Notes & References
- AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals: 2013 Edition
- Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals, 8th Edition , page 123-124.
- For more detailed information and training in acceptable euthanasia methods, please contact Veterinary Services at 824-7788
Confirmation of Death in Euthanized Animals
All research personnel must receive adequate and appropriate training in all methods of euthanasia employed in the laboratory; they must also be trained to evaluate vital signs in the species used to confirm death in the animals. A profoundly anesthetized or severely ill animal can appear dead upon cursory examination; measurements such as lack of movement or visible lack of breathing are not precise enough to declare that a euthanized animal is dead.
Assessment Criteria for Confirmation of Death:
The following assessment criteria apply to all species and for all methods of euthanasia. For specific information about confirming death in rodents and ectothermic vertebrates, please see below.
Heart beat: must be assessed for five minutes or more. The best assessment is through direct palpation of either the pulse in the carotid or femoral artery or direct cardiac palpation. If there is any question, the thorax should be opened, the heart exposed and viewed directly or palpated to confirm lack of activity. Arterial pulse of smaller species may be difficult to palpate, so direct inspection of cardiac mechanical activity is necessary. Lack of electrical activity of the heart as determined by ECG (provided that the leads are correctly connected) may also be utilized to confirm death.
Pupillary response to light: Shine a bright light into the eyes of the animal. A constriction (narrowing) of the pupil indicates a neurological response. Upon death, the pupils will become dilated and unresponsive to light. Some drugs and experimental agents (e.g., anticholinergics such as atropine) can prevent pupillary reactivity or otherwise affect this neurological response.
Respiratory pattern: Profoundly anesthetized animals may exhibit shallow and irregular breathing patterns that may be confused for lack of spontaneous breathing. Thus, lack of spontaneous breathing should not be used as sole criteria for confirming euthanasia.
Rodent Euthanasia - Special Considerations
Rodents, especially neonates, are particularly resistant to euthanasia by overdose of inhaled agents such as CO2 or even injectable agents; for this reason, the IACUC requires a secondary physical method of euthanasia FOR INHALANTS (recommends for all rodent euthanasia), after the animal is profoundly anesthetized, prior to carcass disposal.
Acceptable physical methods for adult and neonatal rodents include:
- Cardiac perfusion
- Removal of vital organs (e.g. heart, lungs, brain)
- Opening of the chest cavity to induce pneumothorax
- Cutting the major blood vessels to induce exsanguination (e.g. aorta, vena cava)
- Cervical dislocation – formal training is recommended (contact Veterinary Services for details)
When euthanizing rodents via CO2 inhalation, one of the above physical methods must be performed after rodents have lost consciousness from the CO2 inhalation.
Note: The above physical methods may not be performed in conscious animals, without specific IACUC approval.
Ectothermic Vertebrates - Confirmation of Death
Additional care must be taken to ensure death following euthanasia in ectothermic vertebrates such as fish, reptiles and amphibians. Such animals may normally exhibit very low heart rates, and the heart and brain are very tolerant to hypoxia; many ectotherms can voluntarily hold their breath for an hour or more. Absence of heart rate and/or breathing will not necessarily provide confirmation of death in these animals; secondary methods for ectothermic vertebrates should always include either removal of the heart or decapitation followed by placement of the head in liquid nitrogen.